The Clash of the Masters of Wine: BLIND Tasting vs. JANCIS Robinson

Welcome to the ultimate battle of the taste buds – the clash of the Masters of Wine! In one corner, we have the enigma of Blind Tasting, a challenge that can humble even the most confident oenophile. And in the other corner, we have the esteemed Jancis Robinson, a true living legend in the world of wines. Get ready for an exploration of two distinct approaches to wine tasting, as we dive into the thrilling world of blind tastings and unravel the insights of the prominent wine critic, Jancis Robinson. Gear up for a journey that will challenge your understanding and perception of wines, as we unravel the mysteries of these wine titans. So, uncork your curiosity and embark on this captivating expedition!

The Clash of the Masters of Wine: BLIND Tasting vs. JANCIS Robinson


In the world of wine, there are two distinct approaches that experts take when evaluating and rating wines: blind tasting and the rating system of renowned wine expert and writer, JANCIS Robinson. Both methods have garnered immense popularity and have their own unique merits. In this article, we delve into the exciting clash between blind tasting and JANCIS Robinson’s rating system, exploring their differences, strengths, and limitations.

Blind Wine Tasting Battle with Four Different Wines

One of the most captivating aspects of blind wine tasting is the element of surprise. Tasters are presented with four different wines, concealed in opaque glasses, without any knowledge of the wine’s origin or varietal. This allows tasters to focus solely on the aromas, flavors, and overall quality of the wine, without being influenced by preconceived notions or biases.

During a blind tasting battle, four different wines are evaluated, and tasters utilize their sensory skills to identify the characteristics of each wine. This exercise tests their ability to discern the subtle nuances that differentiate wines from each other. The blind tasting battle aims to showcase the expertise and precision that tasters possess, as they navigate through different wine categories and evaluate them on the merits of their taste alone.

JANCIS Robinson: A Renowned Wine Expert and Writer

JANCIS Robinson is an esteemed figure in the wine industry, hailed for her expertise and vast knowledge. With years of experience in wine writing, she has cemented herself as a leading authority in the field. Robinson’s passion for wine led her to establish her own website,, which has become a trusted resource for wine enthusiasts around the world. Moreover, she has authored several popular books on wine, providing invaluable insights into the intricacies of the subject.

The 20-Point Scale and Concentrated Scores

One of the distinguishing features of JANCIS Robinson’s rating system is the utilization of a 20-point scale to rate wines. Starting from 12 points, she assesses various aspects of the wine, including its appearance, aroma, taste, and overall quality. Her scores are concentrated between 15.5 and 17 points, providing a narrower range compared to other rating systems.

Different wine categories are rated on different scales, taking into consideration their unique attributes. This allows for a more comprehensive evaluation, catering to the specific characteristics of each category. By providing concentrated scores, Robinson offers a clear and concise rating system that distinguishes between wines with fine nuances.

Tasting Notes: Detailed vs. Lacking Information

When exploring JANCIS Robinson’s wine ratings, it becomes evident that her tasting notes vary in their level of detail. Some wines are accompanied by comprehensive descriptions, unraveling the intricate layers of flavors and aromas. However, there are instances where her tasting notes lack substantial information, leaving the reader craving more insights into the wine’s nuances.

While this may be seen as a drawback, it also allows room for individual interpretation. These concisely written tasting notes offer a glimpse into the wine’s essence, leaving space for personal exploration and imagination. It is this ambiguity that allows wine enthusiasts to delve deeper into their own sensory experiences and draw their unique conclusions.

Blind Tasting vs. JANCIS Robinson: A Clash of Approaches

The clash between blind tasting and JANCIS Robinson’s rating system highlights the diversity of perspectives in the wine world. Blind tasting offers an unbiased, sensory-focused approach, allowing the wine to speak for itself. On the other hand, Robinson’s rating system emphasizes a more structured evaluation that takes into account different wine categories and their specific attributes.

Both methods have their strengths and limitations. Blind tasting showcases the ability to objectively analyze the wine’s qualities, while Robinson’s rating system provides a concise and consistent method for evaluating wines. Ultimately, the choice between the two approaches depends on personal preference and the desired level of exploration.


  1. What is blind wine tasting?
  2. How does JANCIS Robinson rate wines?
  3. What is the 20-point scale used by JANCIS Robinson?
  4. Why do JANCIS Robinson’s scores concentrate between 15.5 and 17 points?
  5. What are the differences between blind tasting and Robinson’s rating system?


The clash between blind tasting and JANCIS Robinson’s rating system brings to light the multifaceted nature of wine appreciation. These two approaches, while distinct in their methodologies, contribute to the rich tapestry of the wine world. Whether one favors the thrill of blind tasting or seeks the guidance of a respected wine expert like Robinson, the ultimate goal remains the same: to savor the nuances and intricacies of each bottle and enhance our understanding and enjoyment of the delightful world of wine.